Skip to main content

The Problem with OERs for English Language Learners

What are OERs?


What's the problem?

I am an advocate for Open Educational Resources (OERs), but the problem is that they are scattered all over the internet.  There are some websites or institutions that attempt to organize them, but many of these have difficulty keeping up or organizing them or making them user-friendly for teachers and students.  Even a simple web search for OERs for English language learners will show that teachers will have to wade through a large number of websites and websites within websites to find a nice clearinghouse of OERs.  For example, I found an open Google group chat that provided an excellent but daunting list at https://docs.google.com/document/d/1-hvzoF-kWWZLacSiiRBYf9etmMtcUPsDQsPxarTZV3U/edit?usp=sharing

This illustrates the main problem with OERs in general.  It appears to me that it is up to the teachers or the department to organize the OERs for their purpose.  Looking at that one resource alone will take days, weeks, or even months to sift through to find relevant resources for an ESL program.

There's another problem

The field of English language learning itself is massive and not as neatly organized as other subject areas.  I have found that most OERs are for public school education, so ELA instructors in this area should not have to struggle as much as others to find good resources.  And I'm assuming some school districts have a person working on organizing them for teachers.

For adults, it gets more complicated because English could be learned in a variety of contexts: community college, 4-year university, graduate programs, English for academic purposes, basic literacy skills, basic conversation skills, basic workplace skills, face-to-face tutoring, online video tutoring, and English for specific purposes. Through my cursory review there seems to be more OERs for basic literacy skills and English for specific purposes, such as obtaining citizenship status. 

There are a few places that have attempted to list OERs relevant to their programs serving adult or higher education students, such as the University of West Florida and Ohio University.

A third possible problem

As many English language teachers know, our materials can become dated so quickly that even timeless lessons or activities can appear outdated if they are presented on an outdated platform.  These materials can become outdated for several reasons:
  • They are dependent on current events and issues
  • They are dependent on outdated technology or websites (for example, this blog post may be outdated by summer 2016).
  • They are dependent on English language teaching and learning "fads" that have gone out of style or shown to be ineffective by research

A solution or three

A professional organization, such as TESOL or NAFSA, or their affiliates can create a user-friendly clearinghouse of OERs.  TESOL kind of offers this at http://www.tesol.org/connect/tesol-resource-center, but some of the resources are only open to TESOL members, so it's not completely open or free.  And apparently these resources are written specifically for TESOL, so it appears that the organization does not seek out or endorse resources published elsewhere. 

Another solution is to have a department or program organize OERs by the student learning outcome for a specific English language proficiency level.  Perhaps other departments or programs with similar learning outcomes can use the same OER website.  Both of these solutions take a lot of time, mental work, and collaborative efforts, so I'm not surprised I haven't seen many good examples yet.  Many of us are too busy helping our own students develop in the classroom.

Finally, the best solution is to have an OER website that is designed very well so that it is easily accessible, user-friendly especially towards technophobic ELTs, and modern in aesthetic appearance enough to make oldies but goodies seem new and fresh again.  This is perhaps the most expensive solution, but may do the trick.

Questions

If you're an advocate for OERs like me, do you think it's worth your time to work on these solutions?  Is it worth your department, program, or organization's time and money?

And finally, if you know anyone interested in collaborating on an OER project for intensive English programs, please let me know.  I may follow up this post with a literature review on OERs and their effects, if any, on teaching and learning languages.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Is Wikipedia Too Difficult to Read?

Image from https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Afghan_man_reading_Wikipedia_article_in_Kandahar.jpg The short answer via statistical analysis is yes .  For more information, read  Lucassen, T., Dijkstra, R., & Schraagen, J. M. (2012). Readability of Wikipedia.  First Monday at   http://firstmonday.org/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/3916/3297 .  Wikipedians are aware that the open online encyclopedia may be too difficult, and there is a discussion of its reading level at  https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Reading_level . Much of this discussion took place over a decade ago, but the gist is that many contributors write at or for the college level. What appeals to me most is at the end of the page, where Wikipedians are discussing accessibility and what it means to be open to all. Here's my screenshot (in case it gets edited later). What does this mean for English language teachers? I was interested in seeing how selected Wikipedia articles range according to
1 comment
Read more

Adrian Holliday

In January 2015, the University of Warwick (UK) hosted a lecture by Dr. Adrian Holliday, whose work has greatly influenced my dissertation.  The lecture was recorded and can be viewed at http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/al/research/groups/llta/activities/events/holliday .  If you are interested in watching the video, I advise that you wear headphones as Dr. Holliday was not wearing a microphone.   For this blog, I briefly summarize the video, highlighting what I found most provocative.  Following that, I explain how Holliday's work has influenced my research and teaching philosophy for the past 5-10 years. Summary of "Revisiting appropriate methodology, BANA, TESEP and 'contexts'" The main purpose of this lecture was for Holliday to reflect upon his book Appropriate Methodology and Social Context , published 20 years ago by Cambridge University Press.  In this lecture, he integrated criticism from another professor whose research I admire, Dr. Suresh Cana
Post a Comment
Read more

TESOL Job Market Trends 2009-2018

I have been tracking full-time TESOL jobs since Fall 2009, my first year as a Ph.D. student at the University of Iowa. Back then, the job market was quite bad because of the 2008 economic crisis. My motivation for tracking jobs was to help my future TESOL students understand the market. This was based on colleagues asking about good locations to live and work. I had hunches but not enough data, and now I have almost a decade of data. What did I track?  In Fall 2009, I started tracking TESOL job announcements from HigherEdJobs.com and the TESOL Career Center for tenure and non-tenure professorships in universities and community colleges. In 2010, I expanded my tracking to include instructor positions at universities (mainly intensive English programs) and "other" jobs, which used to be mainly governmental, non-profit, and publishing jobs. But now they are predominantly in the for-profit higher education ELT industry, including corporations like Shorelight and INTO. In 201
2 comments
Read more